Once upon a time, fairy tales were valuable cautionary yarns filled with dire warnings and sage advice. However, over time, the stories have become so watered down with cute woodland creatures and happy endings that they have lost their true meaning and purpose. No more! This is American McGee's Grimm, and Happily Ever After ends now! In this episode, a destitute fisherman catches a magical fish which offers to grant him wishes in exchange for its freedom. The fisherman is content with his current lifestyle, but his insatiable wife keeps pushing for bigger and bigger wishes: to live in a castle, to be Pope, to be like god. It's up to Grimm to make sure that they both get what they deserve.